Highlights Highlights Main menu Editor's corner More news Contact us Survey information Back issues Statistics Canada home page In depth Français
 
Statistics Canada logo

75-001-XIE

system menu - text links at bottom of page
mast-head for "Perspectives on Labour and Income"
sub-heading "The online edition"

November 2002     Vol. 3, no. 11

Archived Content

Information identified as archived is provided for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It is not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards and has not been altered or updated since it was archived. Please contact us to request a format other than those available.

Earnings over time

Charles Beach, Ross Finnie and David Gray

A recent study examined the earnings of Canadians between 1982 and 1997 to assess changes in the variance of wages and salaries over time and to determine the extent to which these fluctuations were caused by permanent or transitory factors. note 1 

Changes in permanent earnings were measured by calculating the differences in earnings across workers during two sub-periods, after adjusting for age effects. In contrast, variations in transitory earnings were measured by calculating the average variance of the deviations in earnings for individuals around their mean earnings over a sub-period. These longitudinal measurements of year-to-year earnings variations reflect the instability of individual wages and salaries from one year to the next (see Data source).

In other words, a person might have consistently above or below average earnings from one year to another, relative to others of the same age (the permanent component), while their earnings might also vary around their personal earnings profile over time (the transitory component).

Main findings note 2 

l The overall variation of age-adjusted earnings among men increased substantially (13%) between the 1982-89 and 1990-97 periods (Chart A); in comparison, the increase among women was quite modest (1.5%).

l The permanent component accounted for most of the inequality in both men's and women's earnings in the two eight-year periods (roughly two-thirds of the variation).

l The increased inequality in men's earnings between the 1980s and 1990s was due mainly to the permanent component. The transitory component played a lesser role, reflecting some rising volatility in individual earnings.

l In the case of women, the permanent component was solely responsible for the rising dispersion of their earnings over time. In fact, the transitory component worked in the opposite direction by restraining the expansionary effects of the permanent component.

l The variability of women's earnings exceeded men's throughout the study period; however, the differential fell by about half between the 1980s and 1990s.

l The increased variability in earnings between the two time frames was smaller in the more homogeneous narrow estimation sample, which contained continuously employed workers only (Chart B).

The rising dispersion of wages and salaries because of variations in permanent earnings may reflect widening differentials in relatively stable personal characteristics associated with income such as educational attainment and skill levels. Such a trend could be mitigated or even reversed in the coming years with improvements in educational programs targeting youth, and the acquisition of lifelong learning habits generally, including the pursuit of skills upgrading or retraining by older workers.

In contrast, short-term earnings instability among men has declined in relative importance in recent years, while the size of the transitory component among women has been reduced altogether. Indeed, the small increase in the dispersion of women's earnings via the permanent component was limited in scope by the countervailing reduction in the dispersion of their transitory earnings, reflecting general improvements in the earnings stability of working women. These findings should temper concerns over rising earnings instability and place more emphasis in policy discussions on long-term differences in earnings across individuals.

Although this study was based on administrative tax data rather than the Survey of Consumer Finances and the Survey of Labour and Income Dynamics, the findings are consistent over a similar time frame. In particular, declining long-term earnings among young men working full year full time, observed with the survey data, likely contributed to the widening dispersion of earnings noted by Beach, Finnie and Gray. Similarly, the rising earnings of young women may be reflected by the reduced variance of their earnings over time.

 

Data source

The study population consisted of employees aged 20 to 64 during the 1982-97 period in Statistics Canada's Longitudinal Administrative Database. This database was originally created from a 10% sample of Canada Customs and Revenue Agency T-1 taxation files. Workers with a limited attachment to the labour market in a given taxation year were excluded from the analysis (for example, full-time students and employees earning less than $1,000).

The study population was further subdivided into two separate estimation samples for each sex and sub-period (1982-89 and 1990-97):

l a broad estimation sample, which comprised all records satisfying basic inclusion criteria, including workers who reported earning at least $1,000 (in 1997 dollars) for at least two years in the relevant eight-year sub-period, and

l a narrow estimation sample, which included only those persons who reported earning at least $1,000 each year of the applicable sub-period.

Notes

  1. Earnings over time is adapted from a working paper by Charles Beach, Ross Finnie and David Gray entitled Earnings variability and earnings instability of women and men in Canada: How do the 1990's compare to the 1980's. The paper is published by the School of Policy Studies, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario, 2001. A paper of the same title will also appear in a forthcoming issue of Canadian Public Policy.
  2. Unless otherwise stated, these findings are based on the broad estimation sample only.

Author

Charles Beach is with the Department of Economics at Queen's University. Ross Finnie is with the School of Policy Studies at Queen's University, and the Business and Labour Market Analysis Division. David Gray is with the University of Ottawa. Ross Finnie can be reached at (613) 951-3962 or perspectives@statcan.gc.ca.

Statistics Canada FIP identifier Government of Canada wordmark
[ Highlights ]
[ Main menu | Editor's corner | More news | Contact us | Survey information | Back issues ]
[ Statistics Canada home page | In depth | Français ]

© Statistics Canada - Conditions of  use Published: 2002 11 19